Cell and Molecular Biology: What We Know & How We Found Out - 5e

Reviewed by Erica Lannan, Professor of Biology, Prairie State College on 3/13/23

Comprehensiveness rating: 5 see less

The book covers all of the topics of Cellular and Molecular Biology in good detail. It even includes some topics that are not always covered in textbooks in very much detail, such as transposons (pages instead of a paragraph at most). Some topics are comparatively not covered in as much detail, but still have plenty of detail for this level of course.

Content Accuracy rating: 5

All of the content appears to be accurate from my flipping through it. I do wonder about some of the information included on the personal lives of some of the scientists- some of them were so long ago that I would think that do not necessarily have good records of their personal lives.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 4

I think it is easy for the author to update as needed, but with a pdf instead of a word doc for instructors it is much harder for them to make any changes they want.

Clarity rating: 4

A lot of the text is more wordy than I would like. It can provide interesting details but honestly my students don't care about the lives of most of these scientists. Some parts of the book get exceedingly detailed on topics that I would consider more appropriate for courses beyond an introductory text.

Consistency rating: 5

The framework seems consistent from chapter to chapter. Some topics get a lot more detail than others though, some exceedingly detailed on topics that I would consider more appropriate for courses beyond an introductory level.

Modularity rating: 4

The breakdown seems ok, there are some long chapters with relevant parts included. As I mention below, it could be really useful to be able to link directly to certain topics.

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 4

I found it really strange to go into some pretty technical details of cell parts in chapter 1. I usually like to introduce the idea of cells but not get into the details of the parts until we talk about proteins/protein structures, etc. Also, in the biotechnology chapter, it seemed more like "here is this cool research method, here is another, here is another" instead of spending a lot of time on why someone might choose one method or another. Although I liked the challenge boxes, I felt the chapters could be really enhanced by adding comprehension questions to the end of each chapter or better summarizing each chapter at the start/finish of the chapter. Finally, I found some topics in unexpected areas- for example there was a LOT more detail on CRISPR in the gene regulation section than in the biotechnology section. That is fine, but it could be helpful to have a link from one section of the book to another so students could more easily reference the other section when/if looking for more detail.

Interface rating: 4

I found it difficult to navigate back to the main table of contents (since it is on page 12 instead of page 1, you have to scroll to the beginning and then page down until you get there. I also missed the one on page 12 at first and found a different table of contents on page 22. Having the link the the table of contents as a header/footer could make it easier to navigate within the PDF. It could be useful to have all of the links within the table of contents directly to all of the subsections within each chapter at the beginning as well, since many of the chapters are pretty long. I know it would be a lot of work (since with editing some pages may move around), but linking the index pages to the actual pages would also be useful for navigation.

Grammatical Errors rating: 5

I did not notice any major errors. I did notice a few minor issues or typos here and there, for example, in the index the "delta" symbol was changed to a rectangular box.

Cultural Relevance rating: 4

As with most science, the scientists who have been given credit for the work are not very culturally diverse. This is not really the fault of the author or text though.

Comments

I really like the challenge boxes. Those are questions I may ask my students even if we don't adopt the full text. I found a few of the videos I checked out to be really hard to listen to because of mic quality issues for example, (315-2 Overview of signal transduction, 345-2 Rb Gene Encodes Transcription Factor Regulatory Subunit). Others were ok (346-2 Regulating Cell Death). I know that quite a few of my students prefer to watch videos than read a book.

Reviewed by ANJAN PRADHAN, Instructor, Virginia Commonwealth University on 8/26/22

Comprehensiveness rating: 5 see less

It describes the whole content in a concise manner, which can give a whole idea about cell and molecular biology. However, for a detailed study, students should do further readings.

Content Accuracy rating: 5

I dont see any problem.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 5

Content is upto date. New updates can be added easily. The book is most up to date in terms of its contents i.e. it describes about the COVID-19 or SARS-CoV-2 Retrovirus which became a pandemic in 2020 and continuing. The book describes some of the advanced recent research i.e. oncogenic viruses, p53 and signal transduction, G-proteins, protein kinase A and C and others.

Clarity rating: 5

High clarity, no issues.

Consistency rating: 5

Its pretty much consistent.

Modularity rating: 5

Great modularity.

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 4

The organization/structure/flow is fine, can be modified.

Interface rating: 5

I don't see any navigation issue.

Grammatical Errors rating: 5

Grammar is perfect.

Cultural Relevance rating: 3

Not applicable for cultural relevance.

Comments

Title of the Book: Basic Cell and Molecular Biology 4e: What We Know and How Found Out
Author: Gerald Bergtrom

Schrödinger’s Cat, Schrödinger asked that if you sealed a cat in a box with a toxic substance, how could you know if the cat was alive or dead unless you open the box. Wearing his philosopher’s hat (yes, he had one!), he postulated that until you open the box, the cat is both “dead and alive”. This is a great way of starting a chapter and keep students engaging. This book is a masterpiece in igniting the spark in the students towards biological science which is sometimes boring. Similar goes with the works of famous Physicist Richard Feynman. I personally researched more on him, which forced me to read further about his work and end up purchasing/reading his other books.

The book is most up to date in terms of its contents i.e. it describes about the COVID-19 or SARS-CoV-2 Retrovirus which became a pandemic in 2020 and continuing. The book describes some of the advanced recent research i.e. oncogenic viruses, p53 and signal transduction, G-proteins, protein kinase A and C and others. Also, the book covers most of the parts studied in Cell biology, Biochemistry, and Molecular biology.

Some parts that I personally don’t like when it says Google it. Though its helpful and can lead to enhance reading with gain of knowledge beyond the contents of the book, students may not do it. Sometimes, the descriptions are too much philosophical which can be interesting but lacks scientific insights.

Somehow, the book managed to surpass my expectations and what like I expected. It describes the whole content in a concise manner, which can give a whole idea about cell and molecular biology. However, for a detailed study, students should do further readings. Overall, it’s a good one.

Reviewed by Meg Emori, Instructor, Virginia Tech on 4/3/22

Comprehensiveness rating: 4 see less

Index links to chapters for ease of navigation in downloaded PDF.
Material is generally well covered, but is broken up by links to videos and is somewhat hard to follow as paragraph style dives into deeper tangents without first clarifying the big picture/ basics, making it hard to visualize topic simply from reading.

Content Accuracy rating: 5

This text feels generally accurate and unbiased, and no errors were found while reading.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 4

Material relies on some historic experiments/ stories to anchor the narrative (like the "conundrum" of why ATP is required to both contract and relax a muscle). Some relevant details included (like the Chameleon's use of vesicle trafficking to change colors) are interesting and feel fresh without being something that will become obsolete.

Clarity rating: 3

Compared to similar published Molecular Biology texts, this book did not provide as cohesive an overview of the topic, while plunging in depth into examples or details that necessitated jargon. Compared to other Molecular Biology texts, this textbook would require students to learn more vocabulary that might be necessary or reasonable for a typical 2000 level Molecular Biology course.

Consistency rating: 5

While text was not laid out with high levels of clarity, the layout and narrative style is consistent between chapters.

Modularity rating: 4

While divided up into chapters and chapter sections, the vocab words we typically see in units like Photosynthesis are spread liberally across the chapter sections and interspersed with quite complicated new vocabulary. The whole chapter works together, but would not be easily broken up into smaller assigned readings.

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 4

The narrative style is readable. Ease of reading is broken up by links, name/ experiment dropping without clearly explaining the experiment (useful if you as a professor want an example, but not as a student trying to understand by reading the textbook and not going further).

Interface rating: 4

On the downloaded PDF, it is easy to get to the chapter you want, but difficult to have to scroll back up all the way to the index. The index doesn't start until PDF page 10, so you have to scroll all the way back to the top and then hunt for the index again. Many of the microscopy images chosen are not of the highest quality seen in other texts (the axoneme, for example, is a fairly blurry version where the pairs of microtubules are hard to see if you don't know what you're looking for).

Grammatical Errors rating: 5

Grammar flowed well and no errors were found while reading.

Cultural Relevance rating: 4

Of the many scientists and experiments referenced in this textbook, the vast majority are white males. There is little effort made to include all but the most well known of diverse scientists (e.g. Rosalind Franklin). Examples center primarily around white populations, like the NFL football players with Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy mentioned in chapter 3.

Comments

The figures in this textbook centered primarily on mathematical equations or chemical equations, and the figures that tried to show pathways were unnecessarily complicated for a typical 2000 level molecular biology course, or too simplistic (the imaged used for cellular respiration is the pathway chart that shows cellular respiration as a tiny hub in the middle of a complicated diagram, and the ATP synthase image is reduced to red lollipops sticking over a membrane with the legend "the lollipop energy factory will make you shake and dance".) There are no images that clearly and simply lay out, for example, photophosphorylation. As an instructor, less than 20% of the figures would have been beneficial to show to the class as a visual in a ppt presentation to illustrate the topic being discussed.

Reviewed by Zhiming Liu, Professor of Biology, Eastern New Mexico University on 1/11/22

Comprehensiveness rating: 5 see less

This is a comprehensive textbook that begins with an introduction to the molecular building blocks of cells. It then moves on to bioenergetics, biochemistry, genetics, DNA biotechnology, to origins of life. Its twenty chapters cover all aspects of the basic cell and molecular biology.

Content Accuracy rating: 5

The content of the textbook is accurate and concise. With each chapter devoted to a specific concept students gain knowledge and understanding of cell structure and function.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 5

The chapters include updated information from the fields such as epigenetics and DNA technologies, offering students current research and relevant information on the rapidly changing subjects in cell and molecular biology.

Clarity rating: 5

Using straightforward, less technical jargon, this textbook provides clear illustrations of key topics and concepts, helping students understand what cell biology actually is as a scientific discipline.

Consistency rating: 5

Throughout the entire book all scientific terms are consistently used.

Modularity rating: 5

The twenty chapters are presented as blocks of relevant topics in a logical sequence (e.g., basic chemistry, nucleic acids structure, gene expression, biotechnology, etc.).

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 5

The organized chapter presentation provides a clear description of course material, allowing students better understand the concepts and retain the essential information.

Interface rating: 5

Carefully selected external links to supplementary material and well-prepared videos / images engage students and unlock complex topics and molecular processes.

Grammatical Errors rating: 5

The entire textbook is well written and easy for students to assimilate and integrate the knowledge.

Cultural Relevance rating: 5

No other text offers a broader understanding of this exciting science. The book can be internationally adopted for biology majors and non-majors.

Comments

None

Reviewed by Adriana LaGier, Associate Professor, Grand View University on 10/26/21

Comprehensiveness rating: 5 see less

Gerald Bergtrom’s “Basic Cell and Molecular Biology: What we know and How we found out” textbook is a tour de force showcasing his passion for teaching fledgling scientists. The textbook’s comprehensiveness lays bare to the reader that this is Bergtrom’s ‘love child’ and was obviously forged over many decades where each iteration was improved by experience, wisdom and elbow grease.

Content Accuracy rating: 5

Coming in at just over 600 pages, the text covers all the basics and throws in a few delights like the origins of life.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 5

Bergtrom’s periodic updates makes sure that the text stays accurate and relevant. Some topics may lack the depth of knowledge that a parceled book would have. Bergtrom has clearly taken this drawback into consideration by offering word documents that allow instructors to input their own (and perhaps a student’s) expertise.

Clarity rating: 5

Obvious input from students through annotated text makes the text clear and relatable. It avoids unnecessary jargon only an expert would love.

Consistency rating: 5

Textbooks like these are usually parceled out with one leading expert coordinating the effort for one or two units. The consistency in text found in “Basic Cell and Molecular Biology” is most likely a consequence of having an emeritus at the helm leading the charge without a thought to work load fears.

Modularity rating: 5

The textbook is provided as a pdf to both students and teachers so as to avoid interface issues. However, MS-Word files are offered freely (after a day of vetting) to instructors who would like to make changes relevant to their classes. It also allows the text to be easily and readily divisible.

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 5

Not that I intend to change mine too much because it is exceptional not only in its content and supporting videos, but also in its organization.

Interface rating: 5

Worries about whether the bookstore has enough copies or students will inadvertently access instructor resources are a thing of the past. The eText is distributed by UWM. I received all versions (student, instructor, annotated) within a day. And yes, it comes with an instructor version with handy notes from over a vicennium of teaching knowledge.

Grammatical Errors rating: 5

Bergstrom has obviously read and re-read his own text as it has few if any, grammatical errors.

Cultural Relevance rating: 5

No worries taking offense to this text.

Comments

Kudos to the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee for recruiting and retaining such a great teacher and to Dr. Herbert Oberlander for helping to train such a great scientist.

Reviewed by Joyce Kaplan, Part-Time Instructor, Portland Community College on 6/7/21

Comprehensiveness rating: 3 see less

Most topics expected in a cell biology course for both beginning students and more advanced students in majors biology are covered in a fair amount of depth. A few subjects lack the depth expected, particularly in the area of enzyme regulation, which covers substrate concentration and allosteric regulation but not other aspects of enzyme regulation such as pH, temperature, salinity and competitive inhibitors. There is no index of terms, only the table of contents at the start and lists of terms at the end of each chapter. Also the lists of terms for each chapter do not serve as a glossary as they do not link to definitions for the terms.

Content Accuracy rating: 3

The content of the text appears accurate throughout. Most links to outside content were of good quality. However, some were no longer active and others were to “Wikipedia” sites which can have questionable scientific content.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 5

The content includes many examples throughout relating information presented to familiar topics to help students understand how the science fits into their lives. Examples include gluconeogenesis & Atkins diet, clinical value of studying enzyme kinetics, protein structure – sickle cell anemia & Alzheimer’s Disease, connections between specific germline mutations (e.g. BRCA2) and likelihood of illness, environmental causes of epigenetic change, gene editing – power & controversy, applications of biotechnology techniques (e.g. forensics, genealogy, clinical, GMO’s, etc), glycoproteins & human health (blood typing & MHC glycoproteins), receptor-mediated endocytosis & cholesterol uptake by LDL, cancer & cell junctions, cell cycle – cancer & chemotherapeutic agents. All of these were covered very well.

Clarity rating: 3

The text is written in a complex manner and diagrams are small and complex and can be hard to decipher, which can make this text less accessible for beginner students. The first chapter this is particularly seen is in the cell respiration discussion and diagrams which are very complex and often do not show clearly where reactions are occurring, and similar issues are seen in chapters dealing with DNA, protein synthesis, and biotechnology. For this reason, this text may not be appropriate for students without a significant previous biology and chemistry background.

Consistency rating: 5

The text is internally consistent, using terminology that is consistent throughout and maintaining the same structural design in each chapter.

Modularity rating: 5

Each chapter of the text can stand alone well and be rearranged according to the desire of the instructor and college.

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 3

I found the organization of the chapters overall to be confusing. The majority of cell organelles were presented at the very beginning, but cell membranes and cytoskeleton not until the very end of the course, even after biotechnology. While these concepts need the chemistry background to understand, that is why we normally begin an introductory biology course with chemistry before introducing the cell. I think a reorganization of these chapters would make more logical sense.

Interface rating: 2

The biggest issue is that both students and instructors cannot access the text in a normal OER manner where they can read the text directly online without having to contact the author to ask for a copy of it. This can create an unnecessary barrier which may stop some students from seeking access to the text. Then receiving a number of different texts in response is also confusing. Additionally, some outside links that are broken and images that are small or low quality can be issues that affect student learning.

Grammatical Errors rating: 5

No grammatical errors were observed in the text.

Cultural Relevance rating: 5

The text was not culturally insensitive or offensive and made significant attempts to provide historical context for scientific discoveries by a wide variety of individuals throughout all chapters.

Reviewed by Philip Rock, Professor of Biology, Virginia Wesleyan University on 5/31/21

Comprehensiveness rating: 5 see less

This as comprehensive and up to date as any upper-level Cell Biology text I have used. It think is suitable for both higher-level college and introductory graduate school cell biology classes.

Content Accuracy rating: 5

I used this text in the spring of 2020 for my senior-level cell and microbiology course. It is excellent; I found no significant errors.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 5

Extremely relevant and up to date. It has very recently been released as a fourth edition and I am sure this will hold up for many years.

Clarity rating: 5

I enjoy the way Dr. Bergtrom writes. This text really is a pleasure to read!

Consistency rating: 5

Absolutely consistent from one chapter to the next with frequent hyperlinks to both former and future material in each chapter.

Modularity rating: 5

The text is organized in a classic way like other 'big name' cell biology texts. It is easy to pick and choose the material one wishes to present in her or his own way.

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 5

I think the contents are beautifully organized and chose to present my lecture topics in the same way.

Interface rating: 5

No issues here - Dr. Bergtrom has done a wonderful job!

Grammatical Errors rating: 5

Every now and then you might find a mispelled word or a missing punctuation - but you'll have to look hard to find them.

Cultural Relevance rating: 5

I believe Dr. Bergtrom to be a true gentleman. We are talking about an advanced cell biology text here - all humans have the same set of instructions and types of cells and biochemistry.

Comments

I recommend this text highly and without reservation. It is exhaustive in its scope. Every chapter has numerous links to short, informative YouTube videos, challenging questions and references to classic as well as modern cutting-edge experiments that, as the subtitle of the text says: "What we know and how we found out." I learned much from this text. If there could be any complaint, it would be that there is almost too much material for a one-semester class; it could be used for a year-long course!

Reviewed by Meltem Arikan, Adjunct Faculty, Massachusetts Maritime Academy on 6/29/20

Comprehensiveness rating: 5 see less

This book is much more than a regular textbook. It covers quite a few subjects some other books generally omit. However this doesn't interfere with classroom instruction as they are clearly defined and both the instructor and the student can discern what to focus on as the basics for the particular course. Many examples from real life scenarios are provided to make this basic science text interesting to read and applicable to everyday phenomena. Plenty of figures are provided, and they are explained well. The covers all areas that a student of cell and molecular biology would want to know about, usually with detailed explanation of the particular discoveries as well as plenty of links and references. The text is easy to navigate with a lot of links that take the student to relevant points at any point in the text or at other resources, better than a classic index search would accomplish.

Content Accuracy rating: 5

It is accurate and up to date. References are provided right on the page with pointers to relevant resources for further inquiry. I haven't noticed any errors in the text. It appears to be unbiased and provides a well rounded view.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 5

The content of the book is up-to-date. Basic scientific knowledge will be relevant and accurate unless there are substantial breakthrough discoveries in the future that demand major revisions. Plenty of links to dynamic outside resources will make new content easily available to students. These links should also encourage readers to read other related information provided by these resources.

Clarity rating: 5

The text is easy to read. It almost feels as the instructor is talking to the reader. Topics are presented in a clear manner with the learning objectives in mind. Scientific language and technical terms are explained to make the subject clear for a student who is not necessarily familiar with the subject. Acronyms are explained. Figures are well chosen and explained in a visually easy way.

Consistency rating: 5

Contents and the framework are consistent between the chapters. Terminology is up-to-date and easy to follow at the undergraduate level. Even the slides explained in a youtube format are consistent with the text.

Modularity rating: 5

Each chapter begins with an introduction and learning objectives that should help students as well as instructors to focus on the important points to take home. Sub-headings should help the instructor tailor the chapter if they want to cover only certain parts. Although chapters are clearly modular, they are also interconnected to provide an integrated understanding of the overall course.

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 5

Chapters are organized with certain logic to facilitate learning and help the class build on what they learned in previous chapter. However is should be easy for the instructor to make changes to the sequence of chapters if they have the need to do so.
Topics in each chapter are clearly stated and should help students to keep focused while reading the text.

Interface rating: 5

I haven't seen any interface issues with the provided links. Figures are easy to read, and they are clear. Although there are quite a few references and links to outside resources, the instructor can choose the ones that they would want the students to read or watch. They shouldn't confuse the student reading the text.

Grammatical Errors rating: 5

The text is easy to read, and students should particularly like the way the author presents the knowledge in the text. It is almost like he talks to the reader, and explains the subject is a very clear manner. I didn't notice any grammatical errors. Sentences are in adequate length and stay on topic.

Cultural Relevance rating: 5

The text is not culturally insensitive or offensive in any way. It makes use of several examples from different cultures, such as the prevalence of particular genetic conditions in different part of the world are explained in a satisfactory manner.

Comments

This book is great help for science and non-science majors alike. Instructors should be able to utilize vast resources provided in addition to the textbook. This book will be of tremendous help especially when teaching online courses.

Reviewed by Yoshinori Tomoyasu, Associate Professor, Miami University on 2/22/20

Comprehensiveness rating: 4 see less

This is a very nice and comprehensive textbook that covers most of the fundamental ideas in cell and molecular biology. The textbook also covers some new topics, albeit the coverage is somewhat limited. It provides a hyperlinked table of contents, which is handy when you use pdf. However, it lacks page numbers, which might be problematic when you choose to use the print-out version of this textbook. No glossary is provided. There is a list of keywords at the end of each chapter, but no definition/explanation is given to the listed words. This is probably not a big issue when you use the pdf version, as you can simply “command+F” for the word that you want to learn. Appendices contain various useful links, both to the contents of the textbook and to some online resources.

Content Accuracy rating: 4

The contents are accurate throughout the textbook. However, some links to outside sources, especially those that are related to current topics, do not work anymore.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 4

This textbook is very solid on covering the established core ideas in cell and molecular biology, and is arranged in a way that some updates can be added when needed in the future. Some chapters cover relatively new topics. However, the sections that cover new topics tend to be just bullet points with no detailed explanation is given. Instead, most of these new sections rely on external links, some of which do not work anymore. An example is related to CRISPR-Cas9-based genome editing:
“The application of gene editing with CRISPR/Cas systems has already facilitated studies of gene function in vitro, in cells and in whole organisms. Click CRISPR Applications from NEB for a description of CRISPR/Cas applications already on the market!”
This section also contains a link to Wikipedia (not the most reliable source) and a link that does not work anymore.
I’m also surprised that there is no chapter that covers next-generation sequencing techniques or other genomics related techniques (other than a short section mentioning –omics). This is a major deficiency as a textbook for molecular biology.

Clarity rating: 5

This textbook is written very clearly, and most technical terms are very well-explained.

Consistency rating: 5

The organization is very consistent throughout the textbook, with each chapter starting with an outline, learning objectives, historical background, then details. Also, there is a link to a short YouTube video at the end of each section, providing a quick take-home of each section.

Modularity rating: 5

Each chapter is standalone, allowing readers to start from any chapter. But together they provide a larger framework.

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 5

The textbook flows very well, starting from the intro (chapter 1), biochemical aspects (chapter 2-7), basic molecular biology (chapter 8-15), cellular biology (chapter 16-20).

Interface rating: 5

I did not have any problem navigating through the textbook. The images are not of high quality, but they are quite sufficient to explain the contents.

Grammatical Errors rating: 5

I did not notice any grammar issues.

Cultural Relevance rating: 4

This category is not too relevant when reviewing this textbook. However, I found discussions on some controversial issues, such as GMO, rather shallow and slightly insensitive.

Comments

I really liked that this textbook focus not only on “What We Know” but also on “How We Found Out”. Every chapter begins with a historical background, which allows students to connect more to the scientists themselves, their struggles, and their excitements. I think this is a great textbook for introductory-level courses that cover the core concepts in the field.

Reviewed by Christine Terry, Assistant Professor, Lynchburg College on 6/20/17

Comprehensiveness rating: 3 see less

There is a hyperlinked table of contents with fairly descriptive chapter titles. However, the text lacks an index that could be used to find specific terms and concepts by searching directly. There is a list of relevant terms at the end of each chapter; however this is not a glossary, as the terms are not defined.

Content Accuracy rating: 4

The content is accurate and presented at a level that would be understandable to biology majors in an introductory course. However, there are links to outside sources (i.e., wikipedia) throughout. We tell our students that wikipedia is not a reliable source to use as a reference in their writing, and here it is frequently referenced throughout the text. The plasticity and editability of the wikipedia entries could jeopardize both the longevity and the accuracy of this text.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 4

The content is on par with other textbooks on this topic in relation to relevance and longevity of topics. Similar to other texts, it does not describe cutting edge techniques like next generation sequencing. However, it does include relevant sections on CRISPR technology and epigenetics.

Clarity rating: 3

Most of the prose is clearly written, but the clarity is obscured occasionally when ideas could be more succinctly stated. For example, in describing the use of the scientific method, the author writes that the “observance of the method is not strict and is more often honored in the breach than by adherence to protocol!” (pg 2). Additionally, there are some terms which should be better defined, e.g., progenote. I had never seen this term used before, so I did some research. There is some controversy about whether the last universal common ancestor (LUCA) was in fact a progenote; it may be better to use a different term, or at least acknowledge the controversy.

Consistency rating: 5

The text is internally consistent in terms of terminology and framework. Each chapter starts with an introduction, links to voice-over powerpoint presentations, and a list of learning objectives. Throughout the subsections of each chapter, there are challenge boxes which pose questions to the student to help them synthesize what they have just read.

Modularity rating: 4

The text is easily divisible into chapters that can be covered throughout the semester. The topics covered in each chapter can be used on its own. However, the author frequently refers to additional sources in the introductory material for a chapter. For example, in a description of the laws of thermodynamics (pg 57), he states that “for an excellent discussion of how basic thermodynamic principles apply to living things, see: Lehninger AL (1971) Bioenergetics: The Molecular Basis of Biological Energy Transformation. Benjamin Cummings, San Francisco).” While I agree that it is useful to have additional resources cited in the text, it would be difficult for a college student to quickly access many of the texts that he mentions - especially for a topic that is integral to the understanding of the chapter they are currently covering.

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 4

The information is presented logically from beginning to end, although each chapter can be presented individually.

Interface rating: 2

Links to multiple figures are incorrect and figures are not cited correctly. For example, the hyperlink below the comic on page 1 links to a completely different comic on the azcentral.com website. Also, the link below the image of rod-shaped bacteria (pg 6) directs you to the following: http://static.hugedomains.com/images/logo_huge_domains.gif

Grammatical Errors rating: 5

The text contains no major grammatical errors. There are some spots where phrasing is awkward. For example, on pg 407 the author uses the word “size” as a verb when describing the function of molecular weight markers in gel electrophoresis.

Cultural Relevance rating: 4

I did not find any instances of cultural insensitivity in the text itself, but at least one of the links to an outside source was wholly inappropriate for a science textbook. On page 461, there is a link to an article on Huffington Post. The author uses this article to prompt a discussion about the evolution of artificial intelligence. However, most of the text of the article describes Stephen Hawking and Larry King musing on the mysteries of women and the number of Larry King’s marriages. Such issues could be avoided by linking to sources other than Huffington Post.

Comments

I am concerned as to whether the author has license to use many of the images that are in the text. For example, on page 243 the author uses a cover from a 2010 issue of Time magazine and includes the following citation: https://uclareproductivehealth.files.wordpress.com/2012/01/1101100118_4002.jpg. It is not clear whether the author has permission from the publishers of Time to use this image.

Reviewed by Tracy Haynes, Senior Lecturer, Miami University on 6/20/17

Comprehensiveness rating: 3 see less

This text is thorough in the sense that it covers all pertinent topics taught in an introductory cell and molecular biology course. While some processes, such as prokaryotic transcriptional regulation and molecule techniques such as CRISPR/CAS, are covered in adequate detail, other mechanisms, including eukaryotic transcription, cellular transport, ATP synthesis, signal transduction, and cytoskeleton assembly, are summarized but lack details that are appropriate for a rigorous introductory course for majors. Additional information is provided through embedded links to videos and articles but if these are not viewed the student misses the information. Several of these links are to wikipedia which may not be the best source. Also, a more detailed review of chemical bonds and the molecular structure of proteins, lipids, and carbohydrates would ensure the student has the knowledge to understand the cellular processes. While these are topics the student should know from general biology, they often have misconceptions that need to be corrected. This is especially true for protein structure and understanding the allosteric regulation that is discussed throughout the text. A list of important terms is provided at the end of each chapter however, they are not defined in a glossary.

Content Accuracy rating: 3

For the most part, the text is accurate and well written. The sections on energy and enzyme kinetics are particularly well written with excellent examples. However, there are a few errors. For instance, hyperpolarization is the state when the membrane potential of a cell becomes more negative and an action potential is inhibited but it is defined in the text as an increase in depolarization that leads to an action potential. There are a few other sections that need some clarification because they could lead to misconceptions. For example, antiporters and symporters are involved in the active transport of one molecule while an ion diffuses and this is only discussed in the context of facilitated diffusion. Also, the sentence, "On the other hand, membrane proteins are responsible for the selective permeability of membranes..." is misleading because it does not include the role of the lipids. In most sections, the figures are helpful, but without defined figure legends, a few are unclear. For example, the figure on page 110 that describes the electron transport chain is drawn to show NADH donating electrons to both complex I and III.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 5

The text was recently updated so recent references are included. When needed, new references can be added easily so the longevity should be adequate. The text provides an excellent review of the history of molecular and cellular biology.

Clarity rating: 4

Although more details would improve the accuracy and clarity of the text as described previously, most sections are well written and free of undefined technical jargon.

Consistency rating: 4

Each chapter of the text follows the same format with an introduction, learning objectives, and key terms provided. The terminology is consistent and new terms are defined.

Modularity rating: 5

The text is divided into chapters that are each divided into smaller sections with subheadings. Each section is of a reasonable length and the information is logically divided.

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 4

The text begins with an overview of the cell theory and organelle function followed by a review of chemical bonds, macromolecules, and energy. The next section discusses principles of molecular biology with chapters on DNA replication, transcription, gene regulation, and molecular techniques. The last section describes the cell membrane, cellular transport, cell signaling, cell cycle, and evolution. There are a few instances where examples were given that required knowledge that is discussed in later chapters. For example, the tertiary structure of insulin is provided as an example of covalent bonds before protein folding is presented. The challenge questions are a great addition to the text but a few of them needed information from future chapters to completely answer the question. Also, answers to these questions provided at the end of the text would increase learning. Overall, the organization and flow of information is good.

Interface rating: 4

There are no major problems with interface. A few of the figures are a bit distorted but not to the point of distracting from the reading.

Grammatical Errors rating: 4

There are a few typos and repeated sections of sentences but these are rare and do not really affect the overall reading.

Cultural Relevance rating: 5

This is not applicable to this text.

Comments

This text provides a basic summary of cellular and molecular processes that could be customized for an introductory cell or molecular course. There are a few errors that do need corrected and then additional details could be added to supply the desired rigor. The voice over powerpoints are helpful and make the text more accessible. Overall, this text provides a workable foundation for an open access text that can be customized to meet the demands of any introductory cell molecular course.

Reviewed by Kate Kenyon, Associate Professor, Umpqua Community College on 6/20/17

Comprehensiveness rating: 4 see less

This text is a great introductory text that includes the basics of cell and molecular biology. It would be a very useful introductory text. Each chapter includes appropriate video presentations which adds to comprehension. There is a theme based on evolution utilized throughout each chapters with appropriate examples. Main points are reinforced with guided exercises for students. Although each chapter could stand alone it does seem that some reordering of chapters might help. There are some areas that are used but not explained until another chapter. But these are actually quite small.

Content Accuracy rating: 5

Although the textbook us accurate it would be useful to include not only new terms but old venacular such as Krebs Cycle. Since depending on textbook students may run into both terms in later study.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 5

No textbook can be completely relevant forever but I did not find any current information not supported by links which help date the time content was written. It would be easy to provide links to any current new information and future information.

Clarity rating: 4

Whereas the text is very readable and flows nicely, there is no index or glossary provided. Main terms are listed at the end of each chapter but no glossary for accuracy. Plus no index makes it harder for students to find concepts they may need to review in later chapters. I do like that learning objectives are clearly stated in each chapter.

Consistency rating: 5

Whereas each chapter can be taken alone they flow well from one to another. The ease of readability and lends to a consistent understanding. Balance of new concepts is appropriate with not too much new information introduced at one time.

Modularity rating: 5

It is quite easy to have each chapter as a stand alone section with the videos provided. Topics that need information previously presented are represented in a shorter version.

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 4

There is a logical progression that works well. The cellular biology is the last third of the book I would have liked to have seen some cellular presented earlier yet this format does work.

Interface rating: 5

I had absolutely no issues navigating throughout. Since I have not used a Open Textbook I was extremely happy because my skills are somewhat lacking. If I can navigate I think most students will do so with ease.

Grammatical Errors rating: 5

I found no grammar issues that would detract from learning.

Cultural Relevance rating: 5

I found no instances of cultural insensitivity. Examples are very appropriate throughout.

Comments

The illustrations needed more parts labeled and more views so students don't get stuck only being able to recognize one illustration view.

Reviewed by Aimee Hollander, Assistant Professor , Nicholls State University on 2/8/17

Comprehensiveness rating: 5 see less

This book covers the basics of cell and molecular biology and would be useful in an introductory class (100-200 level). I expected more molecular techniques discussed since there was an entire chapter on DNA techniques however model organisms and protein techniques were not covered in much detail if any. The book supplies a list of key terms however there is no glossary or index. A major challenge in understanding the life sciences is grasping the jargon. Therefore, a glossary would be very helpful. The topics covered in this textbook are the topics expected to be covered in this subject area.

Content Accuracy rating: 4

Most of the information provided especially in the text were accurate. I found that some of the illustrations were lacking detail or had additional information which made them less accurate based on the text. For example, when discussing the various subunits of a histone, the illustration for histones does not show these subunits. Also, when illustrating RNA polymerase, the tail is phosphorylated on the enzyme but there is no mention of that phosphorylation in the text how it is involved in the modification of mRNA.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 4

The technology portion of the textbook may need updating as new molecular techniques are developed. In addition to the molecular techniques some of the studies used as examples could be updated. For example, there have been extensive studies in epigenetics done on mouse rearing and twin studies on schizophrenia which could be included in the text.

Clarity rating: 3

I found some of the phrasing and illustrations to be confusing as a reader One example is when discussing the primary structure of proteins “amino acids held together by peptide bonds created by dehydration synthesis during cellular protein synthesis”. I found this to be too much information when the reader had not learned about translation yet. In addition to that statement I found some of the concepts mentioned felt out of order like the author discusses protein modifications after primary structures but before discussing secondary, tertiary and quaternary structures. There was also a lack of specific examples or real world application to these concepts. Protein motifs were discussed vaguely rather than giving a specific example where you might see coil-coil motifs. Enzymes were discussed specifically from a biochemical perspectives and not a cellular perspective. There was no mention of how enzymes are found in various parts of the cells or how the cell is an extremely crowded place. In the DNA chapter the author mentions how size, shape and number of chromosomes is specific to species but does not give us an example or show us karyotypes from various species to clarify this statement. This could continue the misconception that more complex animals have a higher number of chromosomes. Some of the illustrations were also confusing, for example the illustration for primase and heterochromatin and euchromatin are mentioned without an illustration. Finally, I love the idea of the challenges however I found some of the challenges confusing or inappropriate like the challenge on pg 141 in which students are learning about chromosomes but getting asked specific about cell cycles. If the student is being taught in the order of the textbook, then they don’t have a grasp on the cell cycle yet.

Consistency rating: 5

This book is extremely consistent which I appreciate. Each chapter opens with a general overview and student learning objectives. Challenges are added intermittingly throughout the chapter and at the end of the chapter is a table of key terms. Each chapter all consists of voice over PowerPoints and external links for YouTube videos and websites to clarify the material.

Modularity rating: 4

There is modularity to each chapter and it is easy to break up readings. I recommend that header/footers of each page consist of chapter name and topic or subject matter for easy navigation in the PDF form.

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 3

1. . I did not like the way the topics were organized nor the flow of some topics. I would prefer for Cell and Molecular Biology to be presented as central dogma (DNA-mRNA-proteins) then get into gene regulation, cellular energetics, membrane structure and transport as well as additional chapters on cell signaling, before discussing cell cycle, cancer and motility. I also found the last chapter felt out of place and portions of that chapter could be incorporated into each chapter of the book giving an overall evolution theme. I also found various topics felt out of place within the chapter. For example, telomerase was thrown into the DNA replication chapter before discussing the natural shortening of chromosomes after each replication cycle. Also, regulation of transcription was discussed before the details of transcription and regulating of protein turn over may be best placed either in the translation chapter or protein chapter rather than the gene regulation chapter.

Interface rating: 4

I found the textbook easy to navigate although a hyperlinked index or a breakdown of a table of contents would be extremely helpful. Some of the images were a bit lower quality but links to external sources worked and those sources were helpful.

Grammatical Errors rating: 5

No major grammatical errors identified

Cultural Relevance rating: 5

Cultural relevance not applicable

Comments

In general, I think this a good book for an introductory course in Cell and Molecular Biology. I recommend the authors consider challenges or application of topics that are more medically or environmentally relevant. For example, when discussing translation there is no mention of how some antibiotics work, and when discussing protein structure the authors could apply that to various diseases states such as sickle cell anemia.

Reviewed by Alan Schenkel, Associate Professor, Colorado State University on 12/5/16

Comprehensiveness rating: 5 see less

This book is a very comprehensive text for understanding cell biology. Aimed at a biology majors in an introductory class, the book and associated lectures cover both eukaryotic and prokaryotic molecular nucleic acid and protein structures, genetics, metabolism, and even gets into some advanced subjects such as the CRISPR/Cas9 system.

Content Accuracy rating: 4

Overall this textbook is fairly accurate. At times, some more complex subjects or subjects where scientists don't fully know all the answers (such as long non-coding RNAs), the author does describe things vaguely. There are a few errors, some probably arising from the extensive use of online sources. An example is the discussion and image of Alzheimer's disease, which doesn't quite look or work the way illustrated as amyloid beta is miscut and then aggregates. PrPc, shown, is a different protein that does aggregate when it misfolds and catalyzes others to misfold. A detailed re-check of these types of examples should be validated with an expert.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 4

This textbook is up-to-date and appears, as it is in a modular form, relatively easy to update. Linkage to online content is always fraught with issues as content appears and disappears, thus some links do not work currently.

Clarity rating: 3

This is one serious problem for any complex subject. Excessive details and unfamiliar and occasional misleading nomenclature can alway make it hard to grasp. The online lectures work well to help with this. In many cases the author has done a fine job of explaining some of the unusual terminology that arose as scientists discovered the workings of the cells. However, at times, the author jumps around from subject to subject which can be hard to follow. This is reflected also in the overall structure/flow as well.

Consistency rating: 5

Very good consistency overall.

Modularity rating: 5

Each chapter is nicely arranged in modular form.

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 2

This is a serious issue with this book. The flow is too jumpy. The author should reorganize starting with the central dogma (Genes and DNA structure->RNA and Transcription->Protein & membranes) first, then proceed to organelles and cytoskeleton, metabolism, DNA repair and cell division. Finally, the author can then address repetitive DNAs, DNA technologies, and epigenetics. I would hope that students taking this class would already have taken a basic chemistry class first.

Interface rating: 2

The bright blue links is a bit distracting. I'm not sure the purple challenge boxes help, they seemed distracting to me. The images are often of low resolution and poor quality font rendering when in a diagram or image. Italics fonts are hardest read when they degrade. Higher resolution images need to be used. I can see that Dr. Bergstrom has meticulously drawn many of these himself, and they are good, just did not translate well. Perhaps image compression in Adobe Acrobat was set too high.

Grammatical Errors rating: 5

I did not notice any serious errors in grammar.

Cultural Relevance rating: 5

not applicable

Comments

Overall, a very good introductory book. I like the accompanying video lectures. Needs some editing, fact-rehecking, image reacquisition, and reorganization. Dependence on other's potentially transient on-line content is always an issue. But overall a good resource for students in the biological sciences.

Reviewed by Ângela Katsuyama, Postdoc, previously instructor, University of Washington on 8/21/16

Comprehensiveness rating: 4 see less

Overall, without looking into details of every chapter, the book seems to cover properly the subject. The main index is ok. The book has a list of key words at the end of each chapter, but no glossary. The text introduces some techniques to demonstrate how discoveries in the field were made. The beginning of each chapter contains learning objectives, which is a good feature. The book is innovative by being an ‘i-text’, in which the author adds notes, links to videos and allows submission of short assignments. At the end of some chapters, it is possible to direct students to quizzes. It allows customization by different instructors which will probably expand the areas covered in the book.

Content Accuracy rating: 3

Parts of the text have problems with wording, which brings some inaccuracy and confusion. For example, in ‘Proteins synthesized on the ribosomes of the rough endoplasmic reticulum and the outer nuclear
envelope membrane will enter the interior space or lumen, or become part of the RER membrane itself.’ (page 14), I find some issues: 1-) Saying ‘protein synthesis ON ribosomes’ might give students the inaccurate idea that proteins are synthesized ‘on top’ of ribosomes, 2-) saying that proteins can ‘become part of the RER membrane itself’ also might give the wrong idea that the proteins change properties to become membrane. Saying that proteins are inserted into the membrane is more accurate.

It is not clear what ‘status of genes’ page 16 refers to.

Also, in ‘the nuclear envelope and nucleus disappear, eventually reappearing in the new daughter cells.’ (page 16), the sentence gives the wrong idea that these cellular structures just dissipate. Instead, it would be better to introduce the concept of assembly and disassembly of the nuclear envelope, which are highly coordinated events.

As an additional note, despite the fact that the text emphasizes publication as one important aspect of the scientific method, the book does not have any links or references to scientific articles. Instead, it has quotes from Wikipedia, which sometimes might have problems with quality of information.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 4

The book probably will have good longevity. In any case, due to its license and the way the book is designed, it should be easy to make modifications and customize content to add updated information.

Clarity rating: 2

The text is not very clear mostly due to some disorganization and long sentences/paragraphs. It is hard to pinpoint the take-home message of each paragraph. Examples and terms sometimes read like a list. I think that students could have trouble distinguishing what is important and what is not so important to know.

Consistency rating: 5

The text seems to be consistent.

Modularity rating: 1

Poor modularity. The reader will probably be lost with so many subtitles and with big paragraphs densely packed with words. The text is redundant at times and the sentences tend to be too long.

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 2

The text is disorganized at times. For example: under ‘bacterial reproduction’ in chapter 1, it mentions also eukaryotic cell division. In ‘Internal membranes and the Endomembrane System’, it introduces endocytosis, which is an important concept, only at the very end after several examples. These examples could probably come after the definition or in a side note. Cellular structures seems to be presented as if they were a list. I can envision students potentially having trouble focusing on the main points and trying to memorize each term without a real understanding or connection to function.

Interface rating: 1

Unlike most of the other books from the Open Textbook Library, the access to the full version of this textbook is not straightforward. There are three versions: basic, annotated (with author’s notes) and complete (with author’s notes plus assignments). The download of complete version requires filling out a form to be granted access. In fact, I never received a notification to allow the download of the complete version. Therefore, this review is mostly based on the sample chapter (chapter 1), which seems to be the complete version of just one chapter.

Most pictures in this textbook have low resolution, look fuzzy and are poorly labeled. Just a couple of examples: the left panel of the figure in page 11 is ineligible and it is not clear where the ‘arrows’ in the upper figure in page 13 are pointing to. Legends are embedded in the text instead of next to the figure. Therefore, it is difficult for the reader to pinpoint details or sometimes even the main purpose of a figure without going back to reread the text and search for the information. It will likely be more difficult to refer to figures in class, assignments or homework because there are no figure numbers.

Grammatical Errors rating: 3

The text has some grammatical mistakes. For example, in ‘Together with biochemical and molecular biological studies continues to reveal how different cell components work with each other (see cell fractionation, below).’ (page 25), the sentence is missing the subject.

Cultural Relevance rating: 3

I did not find cultural examples to be analyzed.

Comments

I envision that the need of supplying personal information in order to get the complete version of the textbook will hinder access at some level. Overall, the book has nice ideas regarding interactivity, with links to videos, quizzes, notes with questions and mini-assignments. It is also customizable, which is great. On the other side, if I were to use it for a class, it would require a lot of work to adapt it to my liking because the text is densely packed, difficult to read, somewhat disorganized and the quality of the figures is very poor.

Reviewed by Brendan Mattingly, Academic Program Associate, University of Kansas on 8/21/16

Comprehensiveness rating: 3 see less

The text provides coverage of a very broad range of topics, starting with biochemistry, moving into molecular biology, and ending with cell biology. Throughout the entire text evolution is a constant theme, providing context, rationale, and examples of its importance in the biological sciences - a strong advantage and an important one in my opinion. Voice-over-PowerPoint links are made available through YouTube for every chapter, providing guided explanations of the author’s main points. There are one or two guided exercises for students to complete within the text, demonstrating how to use online resources such as those available for creating and visualizing 3D protein structures.

The table of contents at the beginning is very useful in order to quickly identify which topics are of interest, and the links accurately move you to the relevant sections of the text. There is no glossary or index of content, however there is a collection of links to relevant YouTube videos referenced in the chapters at the end of the textbook. Each chapter ends with a list of important terms, but the definitions or the context of these terms is not provided.
The text takes a biochemistry intensive approach to the topic, spending half the text (8 of 16 chapters) discussing basic chemistry, proteins structure, energetics, enzyme kinetics, and major metabolic processes. While some of these topics go into great detail, others do not. For example, the calculation of free energy is given significant coverage, as is aerobic respiration and the Krebs cycle. While photosynthesis is mentioned, as well as the several types of performed by plants (C3, C4, CAM), there is very little information on the Calvin cycle, one of the most important carbon fixation process on the planet in my opinion.

The next five chapters (8-12), focus on molecular biology. Specifically, replication, transcription, translation, gene regulation, and recombinant DNA technology. Replication, transcription, and translation are all approached through presenting ‘famous’ experiments that were done to delineate the mechanisms of what we call the central dogma of molecular biology today. Coverage in this section varies as well. While replication, transcription, and translation are all adequately described, gene regulation focuses primarily on prokaryotic operons. Although mentioned, there is not a lot of information on transcriptional regulation through chromatin remodeling, transcription factor expression and regulation, or miRNA regulation. Processing of RNA is also a little brief in some areas, particularly in mRNA capping and circularization in eukaryotes (which is yet another way gene regulation may occur).

The last four chapters of the text (13-16), focus on cellular biology with a focus on membranes, the cytoskeleton, and cell division. While the explanation and biochemistry of membrane structure, permeability, and transport is excellent, there is very little on intracellular trafficking of vesicles (though trafficking of proteins to particular compartments is discussed). There is no content relating to standard cell signaling pathways. Basic cell structure and function is addressed in the first chapter of the book.

Content Accuracy rating: 4

The textbook is, in general, accurate. Although there may be some outdated terminology (archaebacteria as a primary identifier rather than archaea) or the absence of alternative names (Krebs cycle as the only reference with no mention of citric acid cycle or tri-carboxylic acid cycle), I did not see any serious errors in concepts or mechanisms being presented. The material presented is accurate and presented from an objective scientific viewpoint.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 4

Content is up to date. The majority of the topics are tenets in biochemistry, molecular and cellular biology, and not generally subject to significant changes. There are several examples given to keep material relevant and up-to-date, including a short description of the biochemical ramifications of the Atkins diet and similarly designed low-carbohydrate diets. Discussion of bacterial cell structure in chapter one includes a brief description of bacterial cytoskeletal elements and internal membrane structures (both of which are not present in more dated material).

There are not a lot of cultural references or examples that would become dated quickly, and therefore all the content has a mostly timeless quality. The other side to this is that there is not a lot of ‘cutting edge’ information or modern case studies to describe or illustrate the material.

There are many links to external material (YouTube videos by the author presenting topics, links to external figures, and links to Wikipedia entries) which may become out of date quickly depending on the whims of the institutions that host this content, however, as long as these are kept current they can easily be changed to reflect new URLs.

Clarity rating: 5

The book is written in a very clear and concise manner. It is written in a narrative form with a somewhat casual tone which makes it easy to read and easy to follow. Jargon and technical terms are listed at the end of each chapter as vocabulary lists. Learning objectives are outlined at the beginning of each chapter.

Consistency rating: 5

The text is internally consistent and uses the same organization and framework for each chapter.

Modularity rating: 5

The textbook excels in being able to move between different sections. Each chapter is a self-contained topic with subdivisions. In those cases where information is repeated (such as chapter one’s description of the cytoskeleton and the more detailed approach in chapter fifteen ‘Cytoskeleton & Cell Motility’) the information and figures are presented a second time, rather than forcing the reader or instructor to go back to the beginning and look again. This is quite helpful in being able to present or assign certain sections and still having them retain all the logical connections you would want them to without having to read the textbook in its entirety.

While chapter 14, membrane function, may be a bit ambitious in the amount of material it covers and could be broken down into several topics, it does form a cohesive unit of knowledge on the fundamental biological processes that a membrane performs.

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 5

The textbooks chapters are organized in a very logical fashion, each one building on the other to more and more complicated concepts. There is a clear introduction to the text, though as with many science textbooks, there is no ending or wrap up. There is just an end to content.

Internally, each chapter has a clear introduction and outline to major topics and sub-topics that are being addressed. It is easy to find information when searching for it.

Interface rating: 5

I had no problems reading, navigating, opening, or in any other way interfering with my ability to read and interact with the textbook.

Grammatical Errors rating: 4

While there are a few grammatical errors (such as capitalization for “Thermus Aquaticus”) none are severe enough to take away from the flow or authority of the text. At worst, they are simple technical errors that do not obstruct the meaning or clarity of the information.

Cultural Relevance rating: 5

There is no cultural relevance in the sense this phrase is generally used. The text is not culturally insensitive or offensive in any way. Any examples that are made have no relation to cultural background as they are explanations of natural phenomenon independent of whether humans are here or not. That said, science is culturally relevant to everyone and the more science people do and are aware of – the better. This book does an excellent job of trying to bring science to people and engage them in material that is difficult but approachable.

Comments

This textbook is primarily a biochemistry textbook that has been modified to incorporate cell biology. While trying to cover so many different topics, it is unable to address either molecular biology or cell biology with the normal amount of detail that most textbooks in these fields would have. As a biochemistry text, this is an excellent way to introduce both molecular and cellular biology. As a textbook for a molecular biology or cellular biology course, it may not meet all the content areas desired. The title may be more accurately changed to reflect this focus.