Yoga Minds, Writing Bodies: Contemplative Writing Pedagogy
Christy Wenger, Shepherd University
Copyright Year: 2015
ISBN 13: 9781602356603
Publisher: WAC Clearinghouse
Conditions of Use
The book has a thoughtful and thorough entrance into contemplative pedagogies. It cracks into the field of embodied rhetorics and the juxtaposition of them with feminist pedagogy. It also outlines practical methods to enact "Embodied Change"... read more
The book has a thoughtful and thorough entrance into contemplative pedagogies. It cracks into the field of embodied rhetorics and the juxtaposition of them with feminist pedagogy. It also outlines practical methods to enact "Embodied Change" within the FYW classroom. Additionally, it provides comprehensive exploration of the scholarly discourse that should be considered before as adjustments are made to FYW pedagogy.
It is academic and analytical in its prose. The caliber of the research is of peer-reviewed quality.
References are cited from the late 80s through 2012 and catalog integral voices in the realm of Composition/Rhetoric. It shows the pedagogies leading up to the current climate within Comp./Rhet.
Clarity for this book depends on audience. It reads as a theoretical framework that is accessible to those with Comp./Rhet. background. It will be clearest to those with some preliminary understanding of differing rhetorics--especially embodied rhetorics. It is a book for graduate-level readers and above.
The text is consistent in its use of terminology and adherence to the framework established in the introduction.
For a graduate-level seminar, this book would work well as it is currently broken up. Sub-headings are useful and provide accessibility to the complex topics outlined in the book.
Chapters and corresponding interchapters may be less accessible for those unfamiliar with this structure. However, this move is useful to readers seeking to apply the contextual framework to their own classes. The chapters provide context. Their corresponding interchapters provide tangible ways to apply these contexts within the classroom.
Formatting and presentation is careful and intentional. Navigation is intuitive and linear. Internal hyperlinks on the Table of Contents provide quick access to specific chapters without the lag of scrolling.
The caliber of writing in the book is polished and accessible.
As in alignment with the central theme of this book, "students" as examples are not categorized by demographic markers, which is refreshing. Rather, examples referencing students seem to call more focus to the student as seeking to unify the work of their brain and writerly selves through the mindfulness of the body. The absence of these sorts of markers makes for a text that feels inclusive and concerned with the practical ways students can use mindfulness to become better observers and writers.
This book provides an excellent framework for those wanting a comprehensive exploration of academic discourse surrounding the way current mindfulness-based pedagogies apply specifically to the Composition classroom. An excellent resource for current FYW instructors and future FYW instructors.
What a refreshing perspective to writing! Yoga Minds, Writing Bodies: Contemplative Writing Pedagogy by Christy Wenger is an interesting link of Yoga and writing! The book is comprehensive in areas of promoting writing and developing writing... read more
What a refreshing perspective to writing! Yoga Minds, Writing Bodies: Contemplative Writing Pedagogy by Christy Wenger is an interesting link of Yoga and writing! The book is comprehensive in areas of promoting writing and developing writing skills in learners. The intended audience is those involved with writing pedagogy. It is not a textbook but includes pedagogical approaches. The book has a very holistic approach. It is a good fit for educators who teach writing across the curriculum.
Wegner shares her perspective on writing as linked to yoga. She points out that yoga requires preparation, technical skills, breathing—much as writing. There is a strong holistic focus on body and mind for yoga and writing. A note section provides additional information. There are also references which include credible and scholarly sources.
The relevance of preparing one’s body and mind for yoga is also relevant to writing. The content is up-to-date but does make some pop culture references. The yoga-writing relevance will be relevant for the long term, but some of the pop culture examples may eventually lose some readers.
The book is very clear and easy to follow. Many examples are used. The integration of Eastern philosophy is clear to promote a higher level of contemplation about writing.
The writing style is consistent throughout the book. I like the rich examples that allowed me to consistently visualize the descriptions. The frame of reference is consistent and the author does not contradict herself.
The book includes chapters and interchapters. There is a distinct division of sub-topics that are present and easy to identify. There is also a Notes section to add clarification or further details to certain aspects in the book. Appendix A and Appendix B includes handouts that can be used as activities.
I loved the short interchapters! Nice touch to break up the ideas! The topics are presented in a logical, organized manner.
I did not experience any interface issues, such as navigation concerns or distortion.
The book is free of grammatical errors.
The book is culturally relevant in that it is inclusive, incorporates Eastern philosophy and open mindedness. The author did not say anything explicitly offensive or insensitive.
I enjoyed the way Wegner used yoga to reframe thinking about writing.
The text was very comprehensive. It covered theory, as well as a very well designed explanation of complative practices. Different theories were also discussed, making the text very diverse. The author examines how yoga and the art of being in... read more
The text was very comprehensive. It covered theory, as well as a very well designed explanation of complative practices. Different theories were also discussed, making the text very diverse. The author examines how yoga and the art of being in touch with the mind body connection can help students and instructors alike become better writers. The text is also very comprehensive in explaining how to incorporate yoga into the mind and emotion in order to become a better writer.
The book is very accurate. There is a strong body mind connection and if people can get in touch with this body mind connection, it can have amazing results. Connecting with writing and understanding how we function can be one very important feature.
The relevance/longevity is very good! Yoga is an ancient practice that has been around for thousands of years. We are consistently researching and finding more and more health benefits to yoga.
The book was very clear, it was very easy to understood exactly what the book was about and how yoga could help writers.
The text was very consistent, the content flowed throughout the book. The topics built upon each other and made a strong case on how to use yoga as a body mind connection to help in writing. It also discussed getting in touch with emotions and how students are not encouraged to do this.
The text was divided very easily. In the first chapter the author starts with the feminist theory and highlights three parts of embodiment. The second chapter moves to encouraging student to be writing yogis. Finally the third chapter discusses theory and highlighting how yoga helps with writing techniques, is then discussed after a strong base was set.
The structure built on each other, I would have expected a book with size to have more than three chapters. However, they were consistent and in a straight forward manner.
The navigation, because there were only three chapters was a little more complicated. There were inter chapters which I am not familiar with. It would have been nice if maybe there were some diagrams or pictures it may have helped explain some of the elements of the book.
I did not see any grammatical errors.
The text is in no way culturally insensitive. It is very inclusive and explains theories that are not always used such as the feminist theory. Yoga was presented as culturally significant, and i found the insights to be very beneficial.
This book brought up many areas of yoga that I have not considered. I have taught yoga for about 15 years and this was definitely a new insight.
The author takes an innovative approach to introduce Yoga in the classroom of her University writing students. Wegner hopes they will take this unique experience and make the connection between Yoga and writing on their own. Although this is not... read more
The author takes an innovative approach to introduce Yoga in the classroom of her University writing students. Wegner hopes they will take this unique experience and make the connection between Yoga and writing on their own. Although this is not a textbook, it is an interesting example of teaching outside the box as we see her worlds merge as a student and a teacher.
As an experienced and registered Yoga teacher, I found Wegner's book to demonstrate supporting evidence on the parallells of Yoga and writing. The author references Ivengar, the founder of the type of hatha Yoga in which she practices. She includes explaining intention, body alignment, and the breath work needed to sustain the yoga poses and experience the yolk of the body, mind and spirit. In addition, she uses Sanskrit, the universal language of Yoga, terminology in a way the reader can understand. She strives to move the theories of writing subjects to "writing yogis" by teaching them to use imagination and approach writing with mindfulness in their stories.
The author's experience not as a Yoga teacher but as a writing professor and Yoga practitioner connects the paralells of Yoga and writing by demonstrating a modern approach to introducing mindfulness in a classroom of collegiate writing students. Wegner inspires them to set and intention in their Yoga practice as they would with choosing a topic for their writing. She has her Yoga teacher instruct them with cues to enable them to let go and just be in the moment. In addition they learn to become aware of their suptle bodies and alignment. As her students learn what is happening in their bodies they were able to establish a connection to their own physical practices and write about that. For example, one student talks about how he feels when he is playing baseball. Another student explains her body's movement as she swims etc...
As I am by no means a writing professor, I was unfamiliar with the term 'pedagogy' although I was able to research what that meant. This particular term was used over and over again in the book. In addition if this book was to be assigned to first year writing students, the writing excerpts were a little complex to follow. However, as an E-RYT her Yoga examples and understanding were right on the money.
Again, I was unfamiliar with some of the writing terminology. Her Yoga terminology was very thorough as she not only was able to explain the Sanskrit terminology she was able to have me the reader visualize what it felt like for her to be on her matt. The structure and composition made sense. She enabled my mind to understand how she actually 'got it' as she is learning to live her life as a yogis on and off the matt. The introducition and conclusion were simple but consistent with opening and closing as we do in a Yoga session, which for me tied it all together.
This is not a course textbook but the modularity can definately be broken down in different points if given as a supplemental reading in a course. This book had Chapters in addition to Interchapters.
Wegner was able to lead you through a yoga class virtually with a clear understanding of the experience the yogis has both physically and mindfully. Within the first chapter of the book you could see the parallells with her genius theory of the parallells of Yoga and writing. It was a very clever and brave approach for her to introduce yoga into her collegiate writing course.
I was able to read through this book on a laptop, computer and ipad. I wasn't familiar with open text books and did not know how to save the page I was on, but luckily was able to save the text I was reading under favorites. Her stick figures of mountain and tree yoga poses were a nice addition.
I did not note any grammatical errors.
Wegner married the parallells of the writer to the writing yogis. Not only was she able to translate Sanskrit the Universal language, into English terminology she was able to explain it in a way that made sense to all students including those who have never stepped on a yoga matt before. She is able to site Iyengar quotes with this traditional approach to Patanjali's eight limbs of yoga.
As an adjunct professor of kinesiology and yoga teacher I would be open to recommending this text as a supplemental reading for a Yoga course or an excerpt for potential extra credit in my course.
Wegner's book argues that students can better be taught to write by helping them understand the multiple ways that their bodies are also engaged in this process. She uses her own experience as a yogi to work through how she models this process in... read more
Wegner's book argues that students can better be taught to write by helping them understand the multiple ways that their bodies are also engaged in this process. She uses her own experience as a yogi to work through how she models this process in her writing classes. However, this book is NOT as textbook for a writing class, or any class, so I cannot really give it a score for conmprehensiveness.
Again, as this is NOT a textbook, I cannot address the book's accuracy in that light. Her scholarly arguments are thoughtfully laid out, and grounded in the appropriate theory.
Wegner's arguments about understanding through yoga how the body is implicated in the writing and learning process are extremely relevant given the popularity of yoga in the United States at the moment. In that way, I believe that the book is timely. Too, I believe that Wegner's ideas will have some longevity as university students in physiology, kinetics, pre-med, physical therapy, psychology, biology, and sports medicine programs are studying how exercise affects mood, and are pursuing modes of therapy such as "exercise as medicine" which might eventually change how practitioners think about physical therapy. But again, this book is not a textbook. It's audience is not students, but rather, their teachers who are interested in changing what they do in the writing classroom.
If I judged this book as an academic book, then yes, Wegner's writing is clear and relatively free of jargon, a remarkable accomplishment for many academic books. However, her prose is too difficult for students in most introductory writing classes to understand. I teach at a Research I institution, and I know that my students would be confused if I assigned a chapter of this book to them for use in our classroom. Again, this book is NOT a textbook.
Yes, the book extremely consistent in this regard. The writer structures her thoughts of writing about the body around how her own practice of yoga has transformed how she thinks about the multiple ways that her body is involved in her writing process.
I could easily use parts of this book in a senior or graduate seminar in rhetoric and composition. However, I couldn't use any part of this book in an introductory writing course because the writing level is too advanced for those students. Also, Wegner's book in no way resembles any composition book that I have ever seen. It does not have enough examples and exercises to be a book that could be used to help students understand what constitutes a good piece of writing, and the writing level is too complex to use parts of the book as food for thought in a class where I might encourage students to think about some of the issues that Wegner explores such as the discipline of the body as Foucault described it, or the spurious model of a mind body split that we have been habituated into using in order to understand ourselves and our world.
The writer has chapters and another element that she calls "interchapters." I don't understand what these things are or why they are necessary. Why can't they be chapters of their own, or attached to the other chapters and labeled something else? That element was just too clever by half and really irritated me.
It was very easy for me to navigate this book on my Surface Pro, and I assume that any other student who had a tablet or computer would be similarly able to find things with ease. However, I was unable to do some things with the book that I have come to expect in both PDFs and e-books such as search for a specific word or phrase. That's a shame. I would like to see this book and all open textbooks really structured so that they are searchable as a other types of ebooks.
I did not see any obvious grammatical errors.
This book is a model of cultural relevance. The body is the primary site of oppression, and the writer examines how discipline facilitates this oppression through promoting the idea of mind body dualism. To support this argument, she offers examples of how differently abled people approach writing, as well as of how her students' attitudes towards the writing process changed once they were given mindfulness exercises to consider how their own bodies were involved in the writing posture. Too, the writer's use of yoga as a tool to unpack the idea of mind body dualism is also culturally relevant and sensitive. Yoga is an ancient Eastern practice that has only recently become popular in the west, and some easterners and westerners see this popularity as nothing more than cultural appropriation that has erased the spiritual elements of yoga and turned it into a multi-million dollar industry selling lessons and specialized clothing that plays into patriarchal norms of women's bodies. .
While I love this writer's topic, her book is not suitable as a textbook, at least, not in most college level introductory writing classrooms. The writing level is too theoretical for these level of students, who need writing instruction most of all, and it addresses the teacher rather than these students. However, people who teach writing might find this book useful for helping them develop their own assignments, or even designing a course around the theme of writing about the body.
Table of Contents
- Introduction: From the Sticky Mat to the Classroom: Toward Contemplative Writing Pedagogy
- Chapter One: The Writing Yogi: Lessons for Embodied Change
- Interchapter One: Using "Body Blogs" to Embody the Writer's Imagination
- Chapter Two: Personal Presence, Embodied Empiricism and Resonance in Contemplative Writing
- Interchapter Two: Habits of Yoga Minds and Writing Bodies
- Chapter Three: Situating Feelings in Contemplative Writing Pedagogy
- Interchapter Three: The Writer's Breath
- Conclusion: Namaste
About the Book
In Yoga Minds, Writing Bodies, Christy Wenger argues for the inclusion of Eastern-influenced contemplative education within writing studies. She observes that, although we have "embodied" writing education in general by discussing the rhetorics of racialized, gendered, and disabled bodies, we have done substantially less to address the particular bodies that occupy our classrooms. She proposes that we turn to contemplative education practices that engages student bodies through fusing a traditional curriculum with contemplative practices including yoga, meditation, and the martial arts. Drawing strength from the recent "quiet revolution" (Zajonc) of contemplative pedagogy within postsecondary education and a legacy of field interest attributable to James Moffett, this project draws on case studies of first-year college writers to present contemplative pedagogy as a means of teaching students mindfulness of their writing and learning in ways that promote the academic, rhetorical work accomplished in first-year composition classes while at the same time remaining committed to a larger scope of a writer's physical and emotional well-being.
About the Contributors
Christy I. Wenger is Assistant Professor of English, Rhetoric and Composition at Shepherd University, where she directs the Writing and Rhetoric program. Her research has focused on the intersections between feminisms, contemplative traditions and composition. In addition to bringing her own practice of yoga into the classroom, she has partnered with local yoga instructors to create learning communities between first-year experience courses and first-year writing courses and her research has benefited greatly from the generosity of her yoga community. Her work on the materiality of teaching and the value of contemplative pedagogy for writing studies has previously appeared in journals including English Teaching and Practice and JAEPL, and has been shared at conferences held by the Conference on College Composition and Communication, the Rhetorical Society of America, and the Association for the Contemplative Mind in Higher Education, among others. She serves on the board of the Assembly for the Expanded Perspectives on Learning, an organization that allows her to connect with other compositionists interested in alternative pedagogies. Her additional scholarly interests include feminist writing program administration, digital pedagogy and feminist disability studies.