Native Peoples of North America

Reviewed by Andrea Perez, Instructor, Lane Community College on 8/2/22

Comprehensiveness rating: 4 see less

Well written

Content Accuracy rating: 5

Very Accurate

Relevance/Longevity rating: 5

Relevance and up to date.

Clarity rating: 5

Very clear without being overly simplistic

Consistency rating: 4

The new term are in bold making it easy to look up if unknow to students

Modularity rating: 4

OK

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 3

The subject of Native People of North American is hard to organize but this book did a good job and don't leave out Canada.

Interface rating: 3

I don't see any interface problems or distortion of images or charts. I hope in newer versions that the images and charts can be enlarged.

Grammatical Errors rating: 4

No grammatical errors that I could see.

Cultural Relevance rating: 5

The text is not culturally insensitive at all in fact I believe it spell out the bloody truth of genocide to the Native American people.

Comments

Review the PDF version of this book. I don't think that students will have a problem with the fact that there is no glossary of term. Students can look up unknown terms. I like that each chapter starts with synopsis of a Native American story. These book does not over look the fact that this country was built on stolen for many different Native American people and has a dark pass that involves genocide. The book is very clear that it was not just English immigrants but Spanish, French, Dutch and Russians that all took part of the genocide of all Native American people on this continent.
The Topics in the Textbook cover the general anthropological concepts that will make it easy to understand and enjoy for a freshman class.
It an interesting book well written which will make it relevance for many years.

Reviewed by Rory Becker, Associate Professor, Eastern Oregon University on 1/5/20

Comprehensiveness rating: 4 see less

The range of ideas and areas for Native North America are covered well. I reviewed a downloaded PDF of this open text and, my versions at least, did not have an index or glossary. The lack of glossary was noticeable due to the terms in bold throughout the chapters. Students may find the addition of a glossary that includes all of the bold terms throughout the text quite helpful.

Content Accuracy rating: 5

The information is of high quality and appropriately covered for each topic given the author's stated approach to the text. Moreover, the addition of an Errata following the text is excellent for this type of open source document. Much appreciated.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 4

The concepts covered are basline anthropological concepts that so the book will retain it's relevance for quite a long time. In terms of preference, a fuller incorporation of archaeological data which support the cultural concepts being discussed may enrich the text.

Clarity rating: 5

The author's word choice, voice, and ability to explain complex topics in an approachable manner are well suited to an introductory anthropology text.

Consistency rating: 5

This is handled very well in the text. The use of a native story to start each chapters frames the context for each section nicely.

Modularity rating: 2

This category assumes that Modularity is valued in this type of text. I am not sure I agree that it is and to achieve a higher score in this area the text would need to be organized according to regions, perhaps language groups, or some other topic. The sum loss to this approach is greater than the benefits of Modularity and I tend to prefer the approach the author takes which builds on anthropological concepts from one chapter to the next.

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 5

As mentioned in the Modularity category, I do prefer the author's choices in organizing this text.

Interface rating: 2

Several of the images (particularly the maps) would benefit form a higher DPI or the use of a native digital image. These can be enlarged by the end user which is necessary to clearly see & interpret several of the maps. Image and map choice, however, are quite good.

Grammatical Errors rating: 5

Spelling & grammar are handled well and transparently given the Errata at the end.

Cultural Relevance rating: 1

The phrasing of this category, I believe, is intentionally done to assess the respondant's engagement. For clarity and to be sure I am reading this correctly, this text is the example of cultural inclusivity and receives the highest marks in this category simply by it's topic and approach.

Comments

The text well covers both an introductory course in Native North American and also anthropological concepts. There is good versatility here and the text may work well for a wide range of courses in Anthropology and Native American Studies.

Reviewed by Todd VanPool, Associate Professor of Anthropology, MOBIUS on 1/12/19

Comprehensiveness rating: 3 see less

This is a well-written and interesting book. However, it is not organized according to specific tribal groups. Instead, the six chapters are thematically organized with examples from various tribes being used to illustrate variation or specific themes. For example, Chapter 4 deals with status and political hierarchies, whereas Chapter 5 reals with religion and spiritual beliefs. Many different examples are used to talk about these themes, but the tribal groups selected vary from chapter to chapter and context to context. As a result, it is not particularly comprehensive, in that the reader will not gain a detailed understanding of any particular tribal entity. For example, the Hopi are used as an example of masked dancers (a perfect example), but are mentioned only once elsewhere in the text. A student reading this book would thus understand a lot about the variation and patterns in native North American religions, but would not be able to speak knowledgably about any specific group.

Content Accuracy rating: 5

While it is always possible to quibble, I did not see any glaring issues of scholarship.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 5

Aside from Chapter 1, which deals with archaeology, prehistory, and initial European contact, the text relies on original, primary sources, and applies well accepted approaches to understand them. Chapter 1 is perhaps a bit out of date, but the general text will remain useful for many years to come.

Clarity rating: 5

Well-written and easily understood.

Consistency rating: 4

There are no problems with consistency, EXCEPT that different tribal units are chosen chapter to chapter.

Modularity rating: 4

I think it would be very easy to assign specific chapters in a class as opposed to the whole book. However, it would be more difficult to divide up chapters into smaller readings.

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 4

The text is logically organized, but is organized very differently than the typical text used to teach courses on North American Natives. Most books take a culture area approach, in which a culture area (say, the Plains) is discussed with examples from the culture area. The discussion of each group would be somewhat similar from example to example, and include a variety of topics (e.g., subsistence, kinship, economy, internal social organization, religion/ritual, etc.). This allows students to know comparable information about a number of specific groups, and be able to discuss differences and similarities in various culture areas.

_Native Peoples of North America_ takes a very different approach, and is instead organized by thematic topic. This allows the student to know more about, say, religion across Native North American groups, but they will have a more limited knowledge of general culture areas and almost no general knowledge about specific groups. This isn't a bad thing, but it is different.

Interface rating: 5

Its all fine. The images are very nice.

Grammatical Errors rating: 5

The text is well-written and grammatically sound.

Cultural Relevance rating: 5

I didn't detect any problems or issues in terms of the text's cultural appropriateness. The images are appropriate.

Reviewed by Dr. Katie Nelson, Instructor/Professor, Inver Hills Community College on 8/21/16

Comprehensiveness rating: 4 see less

This textbook is a concise introduction to the study of Native peoples of North America (including the United States and Canada) from an anthropological perspective written for an intended audience of undergraduate students. Using examples from a variety of native cultural groups, the text addresses topics ranging from pre-colonial times to colonial devastation and from religion and art to political and economic systems. The textbook provides a comprehensive foundation of theses topics that can easily be supplemented with additional instructor-selected materials.

Content Accuracy rating: 5

The text is accurate and in general is free from errors or inappropriate/biased perspectives.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 5

The book provides a contemporary treatment of native peoples of North America as dynamic and vibrant cultural groups. Each chapter provides a short example of an oral story that introduces the reader to the chapter’s theme. This adds an emic perspective to the prose.

Clarity rating: 5

The text is written in clear and engaging prose. It is accessible to a undergraduate student audience.

Consistency rating: 5

The text is internally consistent in terms of its organization, structure and content.

Modularity rating: 5

The text is organized into six topical chapters including an introduction and a conclusion. The chapter topics align with typical themes that are frequently taught in an undergraduate cultural anthropology course. This text could easily be divisible into smaller readings and supplemented with ethnographies and other reading materials.

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 5

The topics in the text are well organized and follow an internal logic/structure that flows well from one chapter to another.

Interface rating: 5

The text is free from interface issues and appears to be professionally formatted. The images supplement and support the text and are appropriate.

Grammatical Errors rating: 5

The text contains no obvious grammatical errors.

Cultural Relevance rating: 5

A strength of this text is in how it presents the material from both emic (native) and etic (non-native) perspectives. It also approaches the topic by respectfully, presenting the varied cultural and historic experiences of native people without essentializing them.

Comments

The textbook should be listed under Social Sciences and not humanities.

Reviewed by Margaret Vaughan, Associate Professor, Metropolitan State University on 8/21/16

Comprehensiveness rating: 4 see less

It is a challenge to write a comprehensive text on First Nations in the U.S. and Canada. This is very comprehensive for an introductory text and covers many important terms and experiences. There is room for an instructor to expand on areas the book did not have room to cover and provide alternative points of view. For example, there are different viewpoints on the outcomes of John Collier’s work that the book did not have room to cover. In the different sections of the book focusing on the topic, the Bering Strait Theory is not consistently presented as an explanation less accepted in the field of First Nation Studies, First Nation cosmologies, and by Indigenous intellectuals.There is a note in the Suggested Resources section of Chapter One that includes recent archaeological scholarship about origins of First Nations in the Americas. In the introduction, it is pointed out that “Much truth can be found in the oral traditions of any society…The stories of a society can tell…us as much as any other source of information if we approach them with an open mind.” (p. 17). On a different topic, the simple lack of immunity argument explaining Native Peoples’ community member losses due to epidemic disease is also something that has been made more complex in the academic literature and that is not something included in the text. Additionally, the concept of appropriation of First Nation artistic motifs could be covered in more depth in the chapter on art, as well as in the chapter on religion. The book does not include an effective index or glossary, but it does include a section listing videos pertinent to the book content.

Content Accuracy rating: 4

The text would benefit from many more in-text citation. There are places in the text I would have wanted an in-text reference, although there are a few in-text citations. Besides these issues, the book rates highly in accuracy.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 4

In terms of longevity, there are some statistics that have changed such as the number of U.S. federally recognized tribes. The text is interesting in two ways in regards to relevance. One aspect of the text is to get readers to compare pre-colonization period European societies and histories and Canadian and U.S. First Nation societies and histories. A second aspect is that the text does integrate both Canadian and U.S. First Nation experiences and examples in the entirety of the text. Each chapter has a set of questions that help the mainstream identified student or reader make the chapter content relevant to their life.

Clarity rating: 5

Many terms from anthropology are in bold text and explained using tribally-specific First Nation examples and context from both historical and in contemporary periods in a way that shows the non-static experiences of Native Peoples. Culture is described as “a web” (p. 4) and other terms included are “biological determinism,” "Social Darwinism," "race," and "racism," and "phenotypically" (p. 6). Manifest Destiny is discussed on page five and the painting, Spirit of the Frontier by John Gast 1872 is included as an illustration on page 34. Anthropological kinship terms and terms from the anthropology of religion are included in the book. The chapter titled, “Status, Rank, and Power” include useful terms related to tribal governments including the way two kinds of governments, the community system and the government adopted through Western influence/coercion, in a community may co-exist. Terms are made clear in the book, but there is not a glossary compiling all the terms together. The book is written in an accessible style.

Consistency rating: 5

The text covers examples and contexts from the United States and Canada and keeps an anthropological focus with some historical background included. The voice is consistent—using a friendly first person voice that directly addresses the reader at many points in the text.

Modularity rating: 4

There are a few guideposts included in the narrative to see information in other chapters of the text, but the chapters are lengthy and would also be divisible, in that one chapter could be assigned as a reading. There are no subheadings within the chapters. The chapters are divided into content that work well conceptually as divisible from the book: Chapter 1 In 1491…, Chapter 2: All our Relations, Chapter 3 Resources and their Distribution, Chapter 4 Status, Rank, and Power, Chapter 5 Religion and Spiritual Beliefs, Chapter 6 Is There a Word for Art?.

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 5

The Introduction is not as organized in terms of the flow of the content as the rest of the chapters. However, the actual chapter sections themselves have strong organization, structure and flow. The First Nation-specific origin and “how things came to be” stories at the beginning of some of the chapters work well for the text. The concluding chapter addresses the mainstream identified student to think critically about the course material and particular concepts such as sovereignty.

Interface rating: 4

The photographs are crisp and clear and help illustrate aspects of a chapter. The maps and diagrams in the text are difficult to read and out of focus (in the pdf format) even when trying to enlarge the image. This is unfortunate because they would be useful as content.

Grammatical Errors rating: 5

The grammar is well-polished. The text has some (rare) repetitive word and spelling errors. For example, Greg Sarris’s name is misspelled on page 168. The Native American Graves and Repatriation Act is referred to as NAGPA instead of as NAGPRA.

Cultural Relevance rating: 3

The book does not address Native students (in comparison to how chapter questions may be written directly to students who are members of First Nations). There is one example in the book that refers to living in dorms as students, which is relevant to some students but not to commuting students. At one point in the conclusion, the book uses the pronouns “we” and “us” in a series of questions that the reader may guess to be directed to mainstream identified readers. The book has plenty of strengths for mainstream identified readers to think critically about ethnocentrism, misunderstandings, and assumptions.

Comments

The strengths of this book are in the depiction of contemporary and historical examples and experiences of specific First Nations in the U.S. and Canada and the introduction of terminology used in anthropology. The book is very useful as an anthropological text. Certain chapters may be useful for ethnic studies, religious studies, and Native American government courses.

Reviewed by K.L Cespedes Cortes, Assistant Professor, Colorado State University on 1/7/16

Comprehensiveness rating: 5 see less

Native peoples of North America presents an assessment of Indigenous peoples in the U.S and Canada from an anthropological perspective. As such, the text speaks to the discipline of Anthropology but also addresses the historical influence of Native enslavement and the mission system, imposed conversion, Native American health disparities, colonialism’s altering of food acquisition and the impact of post contact agricultural colonization. The text also provides an analysis of adaptations to spiritual and ceremonial practices, conflict between and among Indigenous populations with the onset of the reservation system, issues of Environmental Justice, and the arts. Pre-Columbian and contemporary information is presented and each chapter incorporates narratives by Indigenous populations that coincide with the theme of the chapters.

Content Accuracy rating: 5

Content of this text is accurate, well researched, impressively comparative.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 5

The content of this text is up-to-date and reflects well the scholarly positions within the fields of Native American Studies, Ethnic Studies, and Native American History. The content is relevant and the text is arranged in a way that if necessary additional information can be implemented easily.

Clarity rating: 5

The text is written in lucid, accessible prose and provides definitions of terminology.

Consistency rating: 5

This text is internally consistent in framework and in the use of terminology.

Modularity rating: 5

This text can be easily realigned with subunits within a course and is divisible into smaller readings for students.

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 5

The topics in the book are well organized.

Interface rating: 5

The book is free of interface issues.

Grammatical Errors rating: 5

The book is well written, and contains no grammatical errors.

Cultural Relevance rating: 4

The book speaks to the historical and cultural experiences of Indigenous populations in North America and approaches the history of colonization with integrity. The text does not however fully interweave the interconnections between Native American populations and other marginalized racial/ethnic groups.

Reviewed by Naomi Brandenfels, Adjunct Faculty- Anthropology, Portland Community College on 1/7/16

Comprehensiveness rating: 3 see less

As a brief text, It covers most areas and ideas of the subject with a few exceptions. I have iterated comments appropriately in each section, particularly in 'Relevancy'.

Content Accuracy rating: 4

Overall this text seems very accurate. The Introduction and Chapter 1 seem to lack some precision in discussing the practicalities of NAGPRA and other concepts more properly focused on by archaeologists including some of the more recent burgeoning information on the peopling of the Americas. On this topic it was very thin. Using David Hurst Thomas 1999 version of Skull Wars is perfectly valid, but there have been much more recent impacts of DNA studies that should be layered onto this information. The Chapters 2-6 had a higher accuracy integrity although it seems as though Bonvillan 2001 was cited as the primary source for much of the cultural information. Many contemporary tribal entities have accessible and well written and cited tribal histories online. As a researcher and a writer that comes from an academic background, I feel as though these are valid sources to find histories as contemporary Native groups tell them in their own voices.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 4

Because of the subject matter, much of this content is up to date, however, with a few exceptions there is a heavy dependence on sources from 2000 and earlier. Much needed is a comprehensive overview of the theories surrounding the peopling of the Americas that incorporates recent discoveries and the resulting implications. Information that addresses the new DNA technologies cannot be ignored by cultural anthropologists and historians alike as they are playing new roles in the stories we tell of the past.

The chapter on art and music as a form of advanced technology is an important comment on what we are taught to valorize and why. I can't see this chapter losing relevancy any time soon. It is a very important chapter and understanding that art is all around us as technology is wise.

Clarity rating: 5

This text is written clearly and is accessible. Terminology is highlighted and explained in clear language. Concepts- particularly difficult ones related to gender and race- are explicit and comprehensible for an undergraduate audience.

Consistency rating: 5

This text is internally consistent with a clear progression of conceptual ideas.

Modularity rating: 4

This book is not overly self referential and Chapters 2-6 would be excellent as a base reading supplemented with more contemporary publications both from the academy as well as contemporary tribal source publications.

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 5

This text is divided into six chapters with an introduction and a conclusion. The chapters are based on some of the expected divisions that we have historically seen in texts of this type- topics that the colonial powers that be consider to be of importance and relevance: resources, status, rank, religious beliefs, and technology. Having said this, I think that internally these topics are approached with a counter colonial subtext and the author uses these topics to create a text that addresses the points of view of peoples who see the world in other ways. The use of oral historical narrative at the beginning of each chapter gives validity to the histories of the groups discussed in the text.

Interface rating: 5

This text is free of significant interface issues and distortion. There are a couple of half blank pages where the image has pushed the text to the next page. It is easily searched with the 'look-up' (looks like a magnifying glass) function on my tablet.

Grammatical Errors rating: 5

Grammatical errors were very few and overall it is written in an accessible voice. There are a few typos, particularly in the introduction and first chapter. The Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act should be 'NAGPRA', not 'NAGPA'. It is 'Beringia', not 'Beringa'.

Cultural Relevance rating: 5

'Cultural Relevance' is one area that would be expected to be high from this particular text but therefore a reviewer needs to pay extra close attention. A key component of this curriculum is to emphasize the variances and nuances in Native American cultures in pre-contact, contact, and contemporary contexts. Although because of the length of this text is brief some generalizations are made between regions, however, there is also caution in making those generalizations. Those that are made seem to be in line with the contemporary presentation of tribal identities. The impact of settler colonialism on the social structure of Native American groups is represented in a way that seems very accessible. Also cogent is the relaying of certain aspects of tribal recognition, land allotments, assimilation, etc. that have a continuing impact. The increasing instances of peoples who self identify as Native American but are not included in communities and membership roles has been contributed to, and complicated by, issues surrounding blood quantum, the recent historic un-recognition of tribes, assimilation practices of the mid 20th century, etc. The marked increase in people self-identifying as Native American on the U.S. census could be considered more fully here in this text, especially with the 2010 census results, but it is mentioned and a critical thinking student will start to make these connections on their own. A couple of things that might be included in an updated version might be the impact of the new genetic identity that people are forming and recent instances that DNA has played in Native America identification. The published 2015 results of Kennewick Man could be an important example. The mitochondrial DNA of Kwäday Dän Ts'ìnchi was identifiable to a specific clan. As anthropologists we may want to consider this new embodied identity and recognize that this may have an impact on identity as contemporary tribes figure out how to relate, or not to relate, this information to their own self governance. Also relevant is the use of oral tradition and storytelling as a basis for understanding and intersecting with the modular concepts by which this text is presenting. Much appreciated is the recognition that these stories are as relevant as the Western originated stories about these peoples as viewed from the outside. The images chosen to illustrate the text were interesting and well connected to the written narrative. They always offered more information to connect these concepts together.

Reviewed by Mary Ann Medlin, Adjunct faculty, Portland Community College & Clackamas Community College on 1/7/16

Comprehensiveness rating: 4 see less

One difficulty with a review for this book is that it is suggested for use in an Introductory Anthropology course (by Schwarz, the book reviewer, not the author herself), as I will do next quarter, for use in an Introduction to Native Nations course. It could be used for either. I think it might be better accepted for a Native Nations course because it clearly acknowledges the limitations of comprehensive example of Native nations' cultures in a single book. It does give some attention to archaeological work which could easily be supplemented by a course teacher. The topics it does cover are comprehensive for such a class and do cover areas critical for Native Nations in a way that should intrigue students of all backgrounds. I usually have Native American students in my courses and I look forward to their reaction to this book.

As a text for an Introductory Anthropology course this would need significant supplements which to me makes it an appealing choice. I would think several ethnographies could be used with this text and a good deal of in class material as well. It could be a good choice for someone wanting to avoid a "canned" publishers package and interested in creative course development. Major cultural anthropology course topics are covered in an introductory level, however less in depth than I would like, again an issue that can be supplemented.

Content Accuracy rating: 3

The book is general error free. I do not think the discussion of cross-cousins is accurate for a society with moieties or any unilineal society where a parent's sibling of the opposite sex would have children which did not belong to their lineage, clan, or moiety.. A mother's brother's children and a father's sister's children would be marriageable in that case. This is important in anthropology for understanding just how significant culture is in defining who we see as kin, and how culture determines so much about our life that is not "just human nature" (as I hear from students). There are a few typos.
Other topics are presented in an accurate manner.

Relevance/Longevity rating: 5

The book is both up-to-date and should remain relevant for a significant period of time. Updating should be relatively easy and straightforward.

Clarity rating: 5

I think the clarity of the book is outstanding but I am exciting about seeing my students' reactions this Winter quarter.

Consistency rating: 5

The book is clearly consistent in both its terminology and framework. I am an anthropologist who using a historian's book for another course that I teach and think this work should also be clear to historians who have some knowledge of anthropological principles.
I almost did not find this book for review because it was not listed under the social sciences and think it could be listed both there and with the humanities.

Modularity rating: 5

I think in general the book is modular. There are some references to material presented earlier but those are explained or could be modified for use in a class using only modules.

Organization/Structure/Flow rating: 5

There is a clear logic to the presentation of the material from an anthropological point of view. For use outside of anthropology the author does include a summary of the organizational principles in the introduction might be helpful as well as specific ideas for other disciplines.

Interface rating: 5

No navigation problem using my Surface. That is the only platform I tried. Images were great. I do require that my students submit doi references for articles in references so that I can access them more easily. They don't often submit a .pdf so I don't know if that is possible for references.

Grammatical Errors rating: 5

I found no problems with the grammar although there were a few typos.

Cultural Relevance rating: 5

I think the material was presented with respect and cultural awareness. The book is about Native American Nation in North American and did include some references to other populations as appropriate. I have found that college students, for the most part, know far too little about the original inhabitants of North American and this volume addresses that issue well. I agree with Stebbins that knowledge of the diversity of Native nations that existed and continue to exist is a critical component of education for college students today.

Comments

I almost did not find this book for review because it was not listed under the social sciences and think it could be listed both there and with the humanities.
That would have been sad and I am glad this has been made available.