Speaking of Culture

Opinión de Julia Baumgardt, Assistant Professor, Marian University on 1/8/21

Exhaustividad clasificación: 4 ver menos

This textbook covers a wide range of topics, from the historical and theoretical approaches to culture to specific aspects and categories of culture, to the particular influences on contemporary American culture. This is a welcome refresher for professors of language and culture and would be an excellent supplement to language curricula.

Precisión de contenido clasificación: 4

While it is impossible for any bit of writing to be completely unbiased, Weil makes a concerted effort to identify bias, misconception, and debunked theories, while also accounting for the limitations of the text. Given the recent events with the Black Lives Matter movement and some of the social reckoning involved, it would be helpful to have some additional material that decentralizes predominant western narratives of America by providing additional perspectives from the African American community as well as predominant immigrant communities.

Relevancia / Longevidad clasificación: 4

As stated above, in terms of the history of the term culture and the categories and parameters it constitutes, this book is and will remain relevant. Additional supplementation will be needed to appropriately problematize some notions about American culture, and additional non-English examples would be helpful.

Claridad clasificación: 5

The prose is clearly and compellingly written, with an academic but accessible tone. Key theoretical terms are adequately couched in context and definitions.

Consistencia clasificación: 5

This text is quite clear about what it sets out to do, the chapters flow logically. While maintaining a level of scholarly rigor, Weil in no way assumes singular authority and acknowledges the areas which warrant problematization and expansion. In this way, the text models the type of metacognition we hope students engage in for their own research and writing.

Modularidad clasificación: 5

There are multiple ways to view this book: e-reader, pdf and reading directly online. The latter is typically the most onerous way to view a text, but I found it quite manageable. Highlighting, paragraph breaks, images and discussion questions all aid in the comprehensibility of the text and encourage good study habits.

Organización / Estructura / Flujo clasificación: 4

The chapters flow logically, text is easy to follow, and multiple subheadings facilitate remixing and revising.

Interfaz clasificación: 5

This book is extremely easy to navigate in pdf and online format. In pdf, the subheadings are linked so clicking them takes the reader directly to that section, which is a very helpful feature.

Errores gramaticales clasificación: 4

This book is clearly written in a conversational tone while communicating academic content.

Relevancia cultural clasificación: 4

Given that this book is written ABOUT culture, it takes a wide but deep view on the multiplicity of components that comprise culture. Sections of this book will be very helpful in teaching students to make discoveries about their own cultures, particularly in the US, which is a first step in identifying and separating oneself to the extent possible from cultural bias. One area that could be improved is the section that discusses race as not a biologically meaningful concept. This is an extremely important point, and Weil did well to be clear and assertive on this front. However, it would be helpful to present the communities and perspectives that in fact do see their race as as significant factor, and problematize a bit more the historical foundations of race and racism.

While not written for language teachers, language students and/or language classrooms, this book provides a solid foundation into the concept of culture for those very audiences. In particular, it will be helpful as American students explore and discover their own national and communal cultures as a jumping off point for comparisons between those and the target language cultures.